Lost Clicks to AI Overviews? A Recovery Plan for Waterford Businesses

Search Console graph of clicks lost to Google AI Overviews for a Waterford heating business

If your traffic has dropped since AI Overviews appeared, start by checking which pages lost clicks and what kind of searches they rank for. Informational pages (“how much does a new boiler cost?”) are hit hardest, because the summary often answers the question. Service and booking pages (“boiler installer Waterford”) are affected far less. The recovery plan is to protect the pages that make money, give people a reason to click on the informational ones, and judge success by enquiries rather than raw traffic. Our SEO service does this review as a first step for new clients.

A Waterford heating firm brought us a graph in the summer that looked alarming. Organic clicks were down by about a third on the year. When we split it by page, the losses were almost all on three blog posts about boiler costs and grant rules. The “boiler installation Waterford” and “boiler service Tramore” pages were steady, and calls from the website were slightly up. The business wasn’t in trouble. Its blog was simply answering questions that Google now answers itself.

How big is the effect?

The research varies, but it all points the same way for informational searches.

Study Finding
Ahrefs, 300,000 keywords, published February 2026 The top-ranking page had a 58% lower click-through rate on keywords showing an AI Overview, up from 34.5% in its 2025 study
Seer Interactive, reported April 2026 About 36% of informational queries showed an AI Overview, against about 5% of transactional ones; CTR on AI Overview queries rose from a low of 1.3% in December 2025 to 2.4% in February 2026
Randomised field experiment, early 2026 AI Overviews cut organic clicks by 38% on the queries where they appeared

The second row is the important one for most local businesses. AI Overviews appear much more often on “how” and “what” questions than on “hire” and “buy” searches. That’s why the damage is usually concentrated in blogs and guides.

Step 1: Find out what you actually lost

  1. In Search Console, open Performance and compare the last three months with the same three months last year.
  2. Switch to the Pages tab and sort by the change in clicks.
  3. Label each losing page as informational, service, location or product.
  4. Open the Generative AI report and see which of those pages are getting impressions in AI features.

You’ll usually find a few informational pages account for most of the drop. Check those queries yourself in Google with a private window to confirm an AI Overview is showing.

Step 2: Protect the pages that make money

Service and location pages are your priority. If they’re holding steady, keep them that way: accurate prices or ranges, the areas you cover, recent examples of work, reviews and a clear way to get in touch. If one is slipping, check whether a competitor has published a more specific page, or whether your page has gone stale.

For a Waterford business, that might mean separate, genuinely different sections for the city, Tramore, Dungarvan and Dunmore East, if you really work there regularly.

Is ChatGPT recommending your competitors instead of you?

We check how ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Google AI Mode describe your business, then hand you a prioritised fix list you can act on straight away. See how our AI search optimisation (GEO) works, or browse our client case studies.

Get my free AI visibility check →

Step 3: Give people a reason to click

An AI summary can explain what a heat pump grant is. It can’t tell a homeowner in Ballybricken what their particular house would need. Add the things only you can offer:

  • Local specifics. “Most of the 1970s semis we see in Lismore need attic insulation topped up before a heat pump makes sense.”
  • Real numbers from your own jobs. Typical price ranges, timeframes and what pushed costs up or down.
  • Tools. A simple cost estimator, a checklist to download or a quote form on the page.
  • Photos and examples. Your own work, with the town named.

Google’s guide to generative AI features says unique, non-commodity content is likely to matter most in the long run. Generic explainers are exactly what AI summaries replace.

Step 4: Try to be the source, not just the result

Pages cited inside AI Overviews still get some clicks and, more importantly, put your name in front of the searcher. Open the AI Overview for your lost queries and look at the cited sources. Usually they’re pages that answer the question directly in the first lines and then back it up. Our post on getting your business into Google AI Overviews covers how to structure those answers.

Step 5: Change what you measure

If you keep judging SEO on total organic clicks, you’ll conclude it’s failing even when the business is fine. Track these instead:

Measure Why
Clicks to service and location pages These are the pages that lead to work
Calls and form enquiries from organic search The number that pays the bills
Branded searches for your business name People who saw you in an AI answer often search for you later
AI impressions on key pages Shows whether Google uses your pages in its answers
Referrals from AI tools Visits from ChatGPT, Copilot and Gemini in your analytics

Our guide to measuring AI traffic covers the analytics set-up.

Questions About AI Overviews and Lost Traffic

Are AI Overviews reducing my traffic?

Possibly, if your losses are on informational pages and those queries now show an AI Overview. Check by page and query rather than looking at the site total.

Can I stop my content appearing in AI Overviews?

Google offers snippet controls such as nosnippet, and has been testing a Search Console setting for opting out of its AI features. For most local businesses, opting out costs more visibility than it saves.

Should I stop writing blog posts?

No, but write fewer generic ones. Posts built on your own experience, local detail and real numbers are harder for a summary to replace and more likely to be cited.

Will traffic come back?

Clicks on some informational searches may not return to old levels. Seer’s data suggests click-through rates on AI Overview queries have levelled off rather than kept falling. The aim is to grow the clicks and enquiries that matter, not to restore every lost visit.

Bring us your Search Console comparison

Export a year-on-year Pages comparison from Search Console and book a free consultation. We’ll go through which losses matter and which don’t. If you serve customers across the south-east, our local SEO service explains how we help.

Services We Provide

Table of Contents

Start With a Free Audit

Digi Wizard delivers SEO, AEO, and GEO in one program. Get a clear picture of what it would take to outrank your competition and show up in the AI answers your buyers are reading.

 
Digiwizard
Know a Business That Wants to Be Found on Google & AI Search?

Help a business get discovered where their customers are searching.

Refer them to DigiWizard and get your next month of AI SEO FREE when they become a client.

1 Referral = 1 Month of AI SEO FREE

No cost to refer • Terms apply